Why reward charts don't work

Star charts are a very popular way to get your child to do something so it’s not surprising that they are often suggested as a way to solve bedwetting.  On the face of it, they don’t seem like a bad idea. All a parent needs to do is explain to their child that they should try to keep their bed dry at night and when they do, they’ll receive a star on the chart as a reward.

If only it were that simple!

Bedwetting is not a conscious behaviour

Having studied the science behind behavioural change and habit formation for over 20 years, I can tell you that there is a big difference between ‘outside behaviours’ that happen in the conscious mind and ‘inside habits’ that have become more deeply embedded on the subconscious mind. Let me explain.

If you want to encourage your child to brush their teeth twice a day, tidy up their toys or put away their shoes each time they come into the house, then a star chart might act as a useful prompt or reminder.  These are conscious habits that your child can easily change with a little bit of encouragement.

Bedwetting on the other hand, occurs at night-time when your child is asleep. It’s extremely rare for a child to set out to deliberately wet their bed at night. It happens unconsciously – and over time it becomes an automatic habit.

Star charts will not provide a long-term solution

A star chart can work in the initial instance by encouraging your child to consciously determine to wake up at night instead of sleeping through.  The effect is similar to setting an alarm clock to wake you up extra early to go on holiday, for example. When you know you have to wake up at 4am to catch an early morning flight, most of us will spontaneously wake up 5 minutes before the alarm goes off. It feels like magic, doesn’t it?

This ‘magic’ effect can last for a few days, but after a while it will wear off.  There is a limit to how long you can keep it up for. It’s the same when we try to diet and lose weight. If you focus really hard on eating healthily you will indeed lose weight for the first few weeks.  As soon as you take your eye off the ball however, your subconscious mind will want to transport you back to your old habits and behaviours.  Because that feels like ‘normal’.

This disappointment will ruin motivation

And once your child’s mind starts to relax and fall back into familiar sleep patterns, the bedwetting habit is very likely to return. So now your child will feel as if they have two problems rather than one – the wet beds and also an inability to achieve those cherished stars. When feelings of disappointment kick in, it will become even harder to stay motivated and committed to solving this problem.

So, my advice to all parents is not to over-complicate the matter by introducing star charts – save this for teeth brushing and other chores. Keep it simple and encourage your child to stay focused on just one thing at a time – and that is learning how to keep dry at night.

 

 

Looking for more structured help and support?

Take a closer look at my series of online programmes designed for different ages and situations:

 

Bedwetting Breakthrough

Mini-course for parents, teachers, boarding school staff and medical professionals with resources to support you. Understand the problem and what actually works

£47

Stop Bedwetting in 7 Days

The bestselling, structured step-by-step training programme for children aged 5–12. Guided meditations for improved sleep. No alarms, no medication.

£147

My Dry Bed

Training programme for older children and adults in their 20s. Practical advice, emotional support, behavioural change in the privacy of home.

£197

 

 

Prefer more personalised support?

Alicia Eaton | Harley Street

While many families find that an online programme gives them the structure they need, some situations benefit from more individual support.

Every young person’s experience is different, and it can be helpful to talk things through and create a plan tailored to your situation.

As a Behaviour Change Psychotherapist specialising in helping families solve unwanted problems such as bedwetting, I offer:

  • Online consultations via Zoom

  • In-person sessions at my London Harley Street practice

  • Ongoing support if needed

  • For more urgent cases and harder to solve problems, I can put together a bespoke package that can include home and school visits.

Anna Hamilton

Designs Squarespace websites that convert visitors into clients. With training in communication strategy and a design background, she brings strategic thinking that helps your ideal audience find you, understand you, and choose you. As a Squarespace Gold Partner, she unlocks platform capabilities most designers miss. Based in the UK, serving entrepreneurs globally.

https://ahstudio-design.com
Previous
Previous

How to prepare for sleepovers and school trips

Next
Next

Do pull-ups make bedwetting worse?